Pokémon Scarlet (2023) Review and Gameplay Guide

Pokémon Scarlet, viewed in 2023 after patches, community analysis, and a full year of player experience, remains one of the most ambitious mainline Pokémon games ever released. It is also one of the most uneven. Its open-world structure, strong creature design, and flexible progression make it memorable, but technical issues and presentation flaws prevent it from feeling as polished as it should.

TLDR: Pokémon Scarlet is a bold open-world Pokémon game with excellent exploration, flexible team building, and a surprisingly strong story payoff. However, its performance problems, visual limitations, and inconsistent difficulty are impossible to ignore. If you value freedom, collecting, and experimentation, it is easy to recommend; if you expect technical polish, approach it with realistic expectations.

Review: A Strong Adventure Held Back by Rough Execution

The greatest achievement of Pokémon Scarlet is its sense of freedom. Instead of moving from town to town in a fixed order, players explore the Paldea region at their own pace. The game offers three main story paths: collecting Gym Badges in Victory Road, hunting Titan Pokémon in Path of Legends, and confronting Team Star in Starfall Street. This structure gives the journey a refreshing rhythm, especially compared with older entries that often felt more linear.

Image not found in postmeta

Paldea is large, varied, and rewarding to roam. Wild Pokémon are visible in the environment rather than appearing through random encounters, which makes catching and team planning more deliberate. Seeing a rare Pokémon walking across a hillside or discovering a new species near a lake is still one of the game’s strongest pleasures. Koraidon, Scarlet’s legendary ride Pokémon, also improves steadily as the player defeats Titans, gaining abilities such as swimming, climbing, and gliding. This creates a satisfying link between exploration and progression.

Where Scarlet struggles is in technical presentation. Frame rate drops, texture pop-in, awkward animations, and occasional camera problems are common enough to affect immersion. While patches improved some stability concerns, the game still looks and performs below what players reasonably expect from a major Nintendo Switch release. The issue is not that Pokémon must be graphically cutting-edge; rather, the world often feels under-finished for a franchise of this scale.

Still, the core gameplay is compelling. Battles remain turn-based and accessible, but the new Terastallization mechanic adds a useful strategic layer. A Pokémon can transform into a crystalline form and temporarily change or reinforce its type. Used well, this can reverse a bad matchup, strengthen a key attack, or surprise an opponent in competitive play. It is easier to understand than some previous gimmicks while still offering meaningful depth.

Best Features

• Open-world freedom: You can choose which objectives to pursue and when, even if level scaling is limited.
• Excellent Pokémon variety: Paldea offers a strong mix of new species, regional favorites, and competitive options.
• Memorable endgame story: The final act is more emotionally effective than the early hours suggest.
• Flexible team building: Visible wild encounters make it easier to build themed, balanced, or experimental teams.
• Terastallization: The system is simple, readable, and tactically useful.

Main Weaknesses

• Performance problems: Frame rate and loading inconsistencies remain noticeable.
• No full level scaling: You can find objectives in almost any order, but some are clearly designed for specific levels.
• Uneven visuals: Character models are improved, but landscapes and towns often look sparse.
• Repetitive side structure: Some Team Star and Titan encounters become predictable.

Gameplay Guide: How to Start Strong

At the beginning, choose the starter that suits your preferred style rather than worrying too much about raw power. Sprigatito becomes fast and offensive, Fuecoco is durable and strong for many early battles, and Quaxly develops into a balanced attacker. All three are viable for the main story.

Once the world opens, avoid rushing in only one direction. A smart early approach is to rotate between the three storylines. Completing Titan battles is especially important because it upgrades Koraidon’s travel abilities, making exploration faster and more enjoyable. Gyms unlock obedience levels and progression milestones, while Team Star bases provide useful rewards and experience.

Image not found in postmeta

Because the game does not clearly mark the intended level order, pay close attention to enemy levels. If wild Pokémon or trainers are far above your team, leave and return later. Scarlet rarely blocks you from entering dangerous areas, so careful judgment matters. A balanced team should include answers to common threats: Electric or Grass coverage for Water types, Ground coverage for Electric and Steel types, and Fairy or Ice options for Dragon opponents.

Useful Team Building Advice

1. Catch broadly early on. Even if you do not plan to use every Pokémon, filling the Pokédex gives you more tactical choices.
2. Keep type overlap low. Avoid building a team where three or four members share the same weakness.
3. Use held items. Berries, type-boosting items, and Leftovers-style recovery can make difficult fights easier.
4. Check abilities. Abilities such as Intimidate, Levitate, and Huge Power can be more important than stats alone.
5. Do not ignore status moves. Sleep, paralysis, stat boosts, and defensive setup can win battles that brute force cannot.

Understanding Terastallization

Terastallization should not be used automatically at the start of every battle. It is best saved for moments when it changes the outcome: surviving a super-effective attack, powering up a decisive move, or removing a weakness. For example, a Fire-type Pokémon with a Grass Tera Type can surprise Water, Ground, or Rock opponents. In the main story, this may seem optional, but in tougher raids and competitive battles it becomes central.

Tera Raid Battles are also an important source of rewards, including experience candies, Tera Shards, and rare items. When joining raids, bring Pokémon that can survive and support the team, not just deal damage. Moves that lower enemy stats, heal allies, or set up defensive screens are often more valuable than reckless attacking.

Exploration and Progression Tips

Paldea rewards curiosity. Check cliffs, beaches, ruins, watchtowers, and isolated caves for rare Pokémon and TMs. The auto-battle feature, called Let’s Go, is useful for gathering materials, but it should not replace normal battling entirely because it gives reduced experience. Use it when farming materials for TMs, then return to standard battles for training key team members.

Image not found in postmeta

It is also wise to visit Pokémon Centers frequently. They serve as fast-travel points, shops, healing stations, and map references. If you are trying to complete the Pokédex, make note of day-night cycles and habitat descriptions, since some Pokémon appear only in specific conditions or locations.

Final Verdict

Pokémon Scarlet is not the most polished Pokémon game, but it is one of the most forward-looking. Its technical flaws are serious and should be acknowledged, especially by players sensitive to frame rate or visual quality. Yet beneath those problems is a genuinely engaging RPG with rewarding exploration, strong creature collecting, and a flexible structure that modernizes the traditional Pokémon formula.

For returning fans, Scarlet offers enough novelty to feel significant. For new players, it is approachable, generous, and full of discoveries, though not always elegant. In 2023, the fairest assessment is this: Pokémon Scarlet is a flawed but worthwhile adventure. Its best ideas deserve refinement in future entries, and its weakest elements show exactly where the series must improve.